Double Dissociation
Double dissociation is strong evidence that two cognitive functions are actually separate, not one thing in disguise.
The pattern:
- lesion X impairs A, not B
- lesion Y impairs B, not A
Broca vs Wernicke
Broca’s Area damage impairs speech production but leaves comprehension relatively intact; Wernicke’s Area damage does the opposite. Production and comprehension are separable abilities.
The question it asks: are these two abilities actually different things?